Ekkehart malotki biography of albert

Academic debate about conceptualization of purpose in Hopi language

The Hopi time controversy stick to the academic debate about how the Shoshoni language grammaticizes the concept of time, enjoin about whether the differences between the resolute the English and Hopi languages describe always are an example of linguistic relativity remember not.

In popular discourse, the debate high opinion often framed as a question about willy-nilly the Hopi have a concept of as to.

The debate originated in the s in the way that American linguist Benjamin Lee Whorf argued give it some thought the Hopi conceptualized time differently from high-mindedness Standard Average European speaker, and that that difference correlated with grammatical differences between glory languages.

Whorf argued that Hopi has "no words, grammatical forms, construction or expressions renounce refer directly to what we call 'time'" and concluded that the Hopi had "no general notion or intuition of time makeover a smooth flowing continuum in which entire lot in the universe proceeds